Check out episode 6 of the Dietitians Unplugged podcast in which Aaron and I discuss the “clean eating” trend. Is this just another way to eat, a diet, or a new religion? And what are the implications for the kids raised in this dichotomous way of thinking about food?
Here is the article that inspired this blog post. Warning: it includes fat-phobic comments and diet talk.
Listen on Libsyn or iTunes. Give us a review on iTunes if you like us — this helps to spread the non-diet love to more people. And feel free to like our new Facebook page!
Re. 20 minutes in — the parents, if they really have “lost” weight (i.e. are not lying or exaggerating), then they are very likely moving into their refeeding phase and/or feeling the effects of protein harvesting on their bodies as their body struggles to return to its normal setpoint. If they don’t practice greater and greater degrees of food restriction, they will return to their normal fat weight, even if they don’t give in to the incredible urge to refeed through binging. The starvation studies after World War II, and studies of involuntarily starving people throughout the world tell us that starving people are mentally ill people. That’s why “clean eaters” are obsessive, bigotted and obnoxious. (Try being a fat person with one of them as a supervisor!) These parents are dangerous. Their kids are at They’re also putting themselves at great risk of heart disease and liver damage, but, hey, anything to be thin and healthy, right?
Yes, in all likelihood any weight loss will eventually be put back on unless, as you said, they manage greater and greater restriction. And even if they manage to keep the weight off, at what cost to their children’s psyche? I think it’s a natural replacement for dieting because since restricting simply for weight loss doesn’t work long term, people now convince themselves that food is literally poison so they won’t eat it. Very sad. Thanks for listening!
Re. 20 minutes in — the parents, if they really have “lost” weight (i.e. are not lying or exaggerating), then they are very likely moving into their refeeding phase and/or feeling the effects of protein harvesting on their bodies as their body struggles to return to its normal setpoint. If they don’t practice greater and greater degrees of food restriction, they will return to their normal fat weight, even if they don’t give in to the incredible urge to refeed through binging. The starvation studies after World War II, and studies of involuntarily starving people throughout the world tell us that starving people are mentally ill people. That’s why “clean eaters” are obsessive, bigotted and obnoxious. (Try being a fat person with one of them as a supervisor!) These parents are dangerous. Their kids are at They’re also putting themselves at great risk of heart disease and liver damage, but, hey, anything to be thin and healthy, right?
Yes, in all likelihood any weight loss will eventually be put back on unless, as you said, they manage greater and greater restriction. And even if they manage to keep the weight off, at what cost to their children’s psyche? I think it’s a natural replacement for dieting because since restricting simply for weight loss doesn’t work long term, people now convince themselves that food is literally poison so they won’t eat it. Very sad. Thanks for listening!
Reblogged this on In Your Face Nutrition and commented:
I think everyone should listen to this, they’re breaking down clean eating and it’s awesome!
If that sign were true, I’d be dead.
True for most of us, I think! The irony was, this sign was at a farmers market and the vendor was selling…BREAD!
Required viewing. Language NSFW, but quite suitable for the subject. https://youtu.be/A1BubC_8Ejc
Oh yes, I love this scene – from one of my favorite movies!
[…] via Dietitians Unplugged Podcast – Episode 6: Clean Eating or Toxic Ideas? — Dare To Not Diet […]